Tips for choosing the perfect diamond for an engagement ring - Davidson Jewels

Tips for choosing the perfect diamond for an engagement ring

 cushion cut diamond

A diamond engagement ring symbolizes love, commitment, and the beginning of a lifelong journey together. Choosing the right engagement ring can be exciting and daunting, with numerous factors to consider and decisions to make. This comprehensive diamond guide provides everything you need to know about buying a diamond engagement ring, from understanding the 4 Cs of diamond quality and selecting the perfect diamond shape to confidently navigating the buying process. By following this guide to buying an engagement ring, you will be well-equipped to find the perfect engagement ring with a quality diamond that reflects your unique love story and captures your partner's style.

Understanding the 4 Cs of Diamond Quality: The Foundation of Your Diamond Purchase

The Gemological Institute of America (GIA) developed the 4 Cs—carat, clarity, color, and cut—to provide a standardized method for assessing and comparing diamonds. Understanding these factors is essential in choosing the perfect diamond for an engagement ring.

4cs chart

Carat: Carat is a unit of weight used to measure diamonds, where one carat equals 200 milligrams. Generally, the higher the diamond carat weight, the larger and more expensive the diamond. When choosing a diamond, it is crucial to consider the recipient's preferences and balance size with other quality factors and budget constraints. For example, a 1 carat diamond may be ideal for some, while others may prefer a larger diamond or prioritize other factors like cut or clarity.

Clarity: Diamond clarity refers to the presence or absence of inclusions (internal flaws) and blemishes (external flaws) in a diamond. The GIA grades clarity on a scale ranging from Flawless (FL) to Included (I3). Although a flawless diamond is rare and valuable, choosing a diamond with slight inclusions that are not visible to the naked eye can result in a more affordable option without sacrificing appearance.

Color: Diamonds are graded on a color scale from D (colorless) to Z (light yellow or brown). Colorless diamonds are the rarest and most valuable, but slight color variations are often only noticeable with a trained eye. It is essential to consider the diamond's setting, as certain metals can enhance or mask the color of the stone.

Cut: Cut refers to the proportions, symmetry, and polish of a diamond, which determine its ability to reflect light and create brilliance. The GIA cut grading scale ranges from Excellent to Poor. A well-cut diamond maximizes light return, creating a visually stunning appearance. When choosing a diamond, prioritizing cut quality can significantly enhance the overall appearance and value of the stone.

Choosing the Right Diamond Shape and Ring Setting: Personalizing Your Diamond Engagement Ring

In addition to the 4cs of diamond quality, other factors such as diamond shape and setting should be considered when choosing the best diamond for an engagement ring.

  1. Diamond Shape: There are various diamond shapes available, with round brilliant diamond, princess cut, cushion cut, and oval cut being some of the most popular choices. The shape of the diamond should be chosen based on the recipient's style and preference, as well as how well it complements the setting and overall design of the ring. For example, a round diamond offers maximum sparkle and is a classic choice, while a princess cut diamond presents a more modern and geometric look.

  2. Ring Setting: The setting refers to the metal framework that holds the diamond in place, with options like solitaire, halo, and Niessing tension rings. The setting should be aesthetically pleasing and provide adequate protection for the diamond. Consider the recipient's style and preferences when selecting the perfect setting to complement the diamond. A solitaire diamond ring, for example,

highlights the center diamond and offers a timeless, elegant look, while a halo setting enhances the size and sparkle of the diamond by surrounding it with smaller stones.

  1. Ring Size and Style: Ensuring the correct ring size is essential for a comfortable and secure fit. Consult with a professional jeweler or use an online ring sizing guide to determine the appropriate size for your partner. Additionally, consider the overall style of the engagement ring, including the metal type (e.g., gold, platinum, or rose gold), the design of the band, and any accent stones or embellishments. A unique ring that reflects your partner's personality and taste will hold special meaning and make the proposal even more memorable.

  2. Matching Wedding Ring: It is also important to consider how the engagement ring will pair with a wedding ring. Some couples prefer a seamless look with matching bands, while others opt for contrasting styles or metals. Discussing preferences with your partner or considering a wedding ring set designed to fit together perfectly is a good idea.

Ethical Sourcing and Certification: Ensuring a Responsible Diamond Purchase

The diamond industry has faced criticism for unethical mining practices, including human rights violations and environmental damage. To ensure your diamond is ethically sourced, look for certifications from organizations like the GIA or the American Gem Society (AGS). These certifications assure the diamond has been sourced responsibly and adheres to strict industry standards.

Establishing a Budget: Balancing Quality and Affordability

Before selecting the perfect diamond, it is crucial to establish a realistic budget based on your financial priorities. The age-old rule of spending two or three months' salary on an engagement ring must be updated and should not dictate your decision. Instead, assess your financial situation and prioritize your goals, such as buying a home, starting a family, or planning a wedding.

When balancing the 4 Cs with budget constraints, remember that there are opportunities to maximize value without compromising the overall appeal of the diamond. For example, choosing a slightly lower carat weight or opting for a diamond with inclusions not visible to the naked eye can result in significant cost savings. It is important to balance quality and affordability to ensure a wise and satisfying investment.

Navigating the Buying Process: Tips for Buying an Engagement Ring with Confidence

Once you have a clear understanding of the factors that influence the quality and value of a diamond, it is time to navigate the buying process. Here are some essential steps to ensure a smooth and secure transaction:

  1. Research Reputable Retailers and Jewelers: Investigate various retailers and jewelers, both online and in-store, to ensure that they have a solid reputation and a history of satisfied customers. 

  2. Compare Prices and Quality: Explore multiple sources to compare the prices and quality of diamonds that meet your criteria. Be cautious of deals that seem too good to be true, as they may indicate the subpar quality or unethical sourcing practices.

  3. Ask for Advice and Recommendations: Seek advice from friends, family, or online forums for recommendations on reputable retailers or specific diamonds. This can provide valuable insights and help you avoid potential pitfalls in the buying process.

  4. Ensure a Secure and Trustworthy Transaction: When purchasing a diamond, always ask for a grading report from a reputable laboratory like the GIA or AGS to verify the quality and authenticity of the stone. Additionally, ensure that the retailer or jeweler offers a secure payment method, a clear return policy, and a warranty or guarantee for the diamond.

       5. Customization Options: If you have a specific vision in mind for your engagement ring, consider working with a                    jeweler to create a custom design. This allows you to select every ring element, from the diamond and setting to                  the metal type and any additional accents or details. A custom engagement ring is truly a symbol of your love                      and commitment.


Choosing the perfect diamond engagement ring is a significant decision that requires thoughtful consideration and research. By understanding the 4 Cs of diamond quality, considering additional factors like shape, setting, ethical sourcing, establishing a budget, and navigating the buying process carefully, you can confidently select the perfect diamond to symbolize your love and commitment. 

When shopping for the perfect ring, consider visiting Calgary-based jeweler and custom designer Davidson Jewels. With a strong reputation for exceptional craftsmanship, personalized service, and commitment to ethical sourcing, Davidson Jewels is an ideal choice for couples seeking a unique and meaningful symbol of their love. Their team of experienced designers and artisans will work closely with you to create a one-of-a-kind engagement ring, tailored to your partner's style and preferences. By incorporating elements such as hand-selected GIA diamonds, precious metals, and intricate design details, Davidson Jewels ensures that your custom engagement ring is not only an exquisite piece of art but also a cherished representation of your love story.

Back to blog